What is Email Sender Reputation?

ESPs, or mailbox providers, use a reputation score to gauge how trustworthy your emails are. This score then determines whether your emails land in the inbox or the spam folder.


The higher your reputation score, the greater trust you have with ESPs. Think of it as your email’s social credit score. But it monitors your email sending habits instead of tracking your online shopping habits.


This boosts the chances of your emails reaching your customers’ inboxes. Each provider has its own method for assessing sender reputation, but they broadly use the same two key indicators:

  1. IP Reputation

    This is the trustworthiness of the internet address (IP) used to send emails. Shared IPs, often used by bulk emailers, can take a hit if other senders on that IP engage in spammy practices.

  2. Domain Reputation

    This reflects the history of emails sent from your specific domain (e.g., yourcompany.com). A history of high bounce rates or spam complaints can tarnish your domain’s reputation. Your email sender reputation is a combined score between your IP and domain reputation.


So, how does this reputation impact your emails?


Simple: Your sender reputation directly influences email deliverability. ISPs (Internet Service Providers) use this score to filter out potential spam. A bad reputation can lead to your emails getting:


  • Filtered to spam: This is email purgatory – recipients might miss your important messages altogether.


  • Blocked entirely: ISPs might block emails from your domain altogether if your reputation is very low.



What Affects Your Sender Reputation?

So what factors contribute towards sender reputation?


As mentioned, each provider has their own methodology when it comes to assessing your email sender score. However, there are several elements that all providers look at to determine reputation. These include:

  • Email Engagement

    High open rates, click-through rates, and low unsubscribe rates positively impact your reputation. Conversely, low engagement or frequent spam complaints can damage it.

  • Bounce Rates

    Emails that can’t be delivered and bounce back to you can hurt your reputation.

  • Spam Complaints

    If recipients mark your emails as spam, it signals to email providers that your content might be unwelcome.

  • Sending Volume

    Sudden spikes in sending volume can trigger red flags for spam filters. Consistent, predictable email volume is ideal.

  • Authentication

    Properly set up email authentication protocols like SPF, DKIM, and DMARC help verify your identity and improve your reputation.


How to Check Your Email Sender Reputation

Here are some handy tools to check your reputation:

  • Sender Score

    Imagine a credit score for your email sending. Sender Score gives you a number (0-100) on how trustworthy email providers see your IP address. The higher the score, the more likely your email will go to the recipient’s inbox, and not their spam filter

  • Talos Intelligence:

    This intel comes from Cisco, a cybersecurity giant. Talos Intelligence lets you check the reputation of both your IP address and domain name. Having a clean record with them ensures a smooth email journey.

  • Google Postmaster Tools:

    Gmail is a juggernaut in the email world, so their insights are gold. Postmaster Tools give you a peek at how Gmail views your domain’s reputation, including helpful stats and tips to improve deliverability.

  • MxToolbox

    This all-in-one toolbox includes a reputation checker to see how email providers view your IP and domain. Plus, it offers blacklist monitoring, so you can catch any potential issues before they affect your emails.


Keeping an eye on your sender reputation with these tools is like having a pit crew for your email marketing. By monitoring and improving your score, you’ll ensure your messages reach the intended inboxes, keeping your audience engaged and happy, and out of the spam folder.



6 Ways to Improve Your Sender Reputation

A solid sender reputation doesn’t happen overnight, but with these tips, you can enhance it:



1. Respect the Recipient’s Inbox

First things first: respect your audience’s inbox. Forget about buying email lists (they’re often inaccurate and can hurt your reputation). Focus on confirmed opt-ins, where people willingly sign up to receive your emails. Here’s how:


  • Offer Valuable Incentives: Entice people with freebies like ebooks, cheat sheets, or exclusive discounts.


  • Crystal Clear Opt-In Forms: Make sure your signup forms are easy to find and understand. Clearly state what type of content they’ll receive and how often.


  • Double Opt-In: Send a confirmation email after someone signs up. This verifies their address and builds trust from the get-go.



2. Monitor Engagement

Not all subscribers are created equal. Some devour your emails, while others might just be collecting dust. Here’s how to track engagement and tailor your content accordingly:


  • Open and Click-Through Rates: These metrics tell you how many people open your emails and click on the links within. Low rates? Experiment with subject lines, email length, or content format.


  • A/B Testing: Test different email versions to see which resonates better. Try different headlines, calls to action, or even sending times.


  • Segmentation: Group subscribers based on interests or behavior. This allows you to send more targeted and relevant content.



3. Implement Authentication Protocols

Imagine showing up to a party uninvited. That’s what happens when your emails lack proper authentication. Here’s how to ensure your messages land in inboxes, not spam folders:


  • Set Up SPF, DKIM, and DMARC Records: These technical configurations basically verify your identity as a legitimate sender.


Don’t worry, most email marketing platforms guide you through this process.



4. Avoid Spam Traps

Spam traps are email addresses used to catch spammers. Sending emails to them can seriously hurt your reputation. Here’s how to maintain a clean list:


  • Regular List Hygiene: Schedule regular cleanings to remove inactive subscribers (those who haven’t opened your emails in a long time) and invalid addresses (bounced emails).


  • Let People Go Gracefully: Make it easy for people to unsubscribe. A clear unsubscribe link in every email shows you respect their inbox space.



5. Handle Complaints Gracefully

Even the best emails might spark an unsubscribe or complaint. Here’s how to respond gracefully:


  • Easy Unsubscribe Options: Make it a one-click process. Frustrated people won’t be shy about marking you as spam if it’s difficult to unsubscribe.


  • Address Concerns Promptly: If someone complains, respond quickly and professionally. Take their feedback seriously and use it to improve your future emails.



6. Maintain Consistent Sending Patterns

Imagine getting bombarded with emails after a long period of silence. It can feel overwhelming. Here’s how to build trust with consistent sending patterns:


  • Start Slow and Gradually Increase: Don’t overwhelm your audience. Begin with a consistent sending frequency and gradually increase it as engagement grows.


  • Maintain a Schedule: People appreciate knowing when to expect your emails. Plan your content calendar in advance and stick to a consistent sending schedule.




Your email sender reputation is your key to successful email marketing and communication. By understanding and managing your IP and domain reputation, monitoring key factors, and using the right tools, you can significantly enhance your email deliverability.


Building a quality list takes time and effort, but the payoff is incredible. By following these tips, you’ll create a community of engaged subscribers who are genuinely interested in what you have to offer.

Gain Communication Clarity with Spike